Yes and No. Typically, topping-off an API CJ-4 product with an API CI-4 PLUS oil is not recommended. There are some exceptions, depending on the model year of the engine. To further explain, if you are using API CJ-4 oil in pre-2007 engines, if necessary, you can top-off with an API CI-4 PLUS oil. API CI-4 PLUS oil meets all the requirements for pre-2007 engines.
In 2007 model year engines, API CJ-4 oils must be used and you cannot top-off with an API CI-4 PLUS oil. However, if the choice is low oil level or using API CI-4 PLUS oil, add the API CI-4 PLUS oil, but change the oil as soon as possible.